The great exchange
Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn was a Russian writer during the Soviet era. He asked whether evil could be eradicated from the world, but concluded that this was impossible: good and evil run through every human heart, so removing evil would mean cutting away part of ourselves. Do you agree with this view of human nature? (Paraphrase.)
The video is in Bulgarian.
Jesus stands before a Roman governor, facing charges that could bring a death sentence. Hostile crowds demand his crucifixion. Yet he refuses to defend himself. Why?
Discuss
Historical context:
The religious leaders have decided to kill Jesus because he claims equality with God. Their opportunity comes when Judas, one of Jesus’ disciples, agrees to help them arrest him.
Jesus is arrested and subjected to an unfair trial based on false evidence.
The verdict is that he deserves to die. Because the Jewish court, the Sanhedrin, has no authority to impose a death sentence, the religious leaders bring Jesus before the Roman governor Pilate.
Question 1
Describe the disciples’ attitude towards Jesus. Why do they treat him this way?
Question 2
What does Pilate ask about Jesus in verses 4-6?
Question 3
Why is Pilate afraid when he hears the accusations against Jesus in verses 7-8?
Question 4
Jesus stands before a man with the power to kill him. What strikes you about their conversation in verses 9-11? Who seems more afraid?
Read verses 12-16. Pilate hopes to release Jesus. How do the religious leaders finally persuade him to have Jesus killed?
Question 5
Jesus has already endured an unjust trial and a painful flogging. Now he is forced to carry his cross through the crowds in Jerusalem’s streets. Can you imagine the physical pain he feels?
In one short sentence, John tells us that Jesus was crucified. Crucifixion was one of the most horrific and painful punishments ever devised. It warned people against defying the Roman Empire. Part of the punishment involved placing a notice above the victim’s head stating the offence. For Jewish people, this was a particularly shameful way to die because the Old Testament says that anyone killed in this way is under a curse.
Question 6
Jesus’ mother and some of his followers stand near the cross (verses 25-27). How do you think they feel? What might they think now about Jesus’ claim to be the Saviour of the world, sent by God?
Question 7
Jesus appears to have failed. Yet is there evidence that he is still in control of the situation (verses 28-30)?
When John writes about the crucifixion, he often points readers to Old Testament prophecies about the Messiah. Isaiah wrote around 700 years before Jesus was born. He describes what would happen and how it would affect the world:
He was despised and rejected by people,
a man of suffering, familiar with illness,
and we turned our faces away from him;
he was despised, and we counted him as nothing.
Yet he took our illnesses upon himself
and carried our suffering,
while we thought God had struck, punished and humiliated him.
But he was pierced because of our sins
and struck because of our wrongdoing.
The punishment fell upon him
that brought about our salvation,
and through his wounds we were healed.
We all wandered away like sheep;
each of us followed our own way.
But the Lord placed all our sins upon him. (Isaiah 53:3-6)
Question 8
How do these words relate to what Jesus experienced? According to Isaiah, what problem would the Messiah face, and how would he resolve it?
Before dying, Jesus says, “I am thirsty.” In John’s Gospel, thirst represents our separation from God because of sin. At this moment, Jesus experiences God’s judgement, but not for his own sins. He is innocent, as Pilate repeatedly says. The punishment of separation from God and the death we deserve are placed on Jesus so that we can have peace with God.
Question 9
With his final breath, Jesus cries, “It is finished.” What do you think Jesus believed his death on the cross would accomplish?
Question 10
Nicodemus, a respected Jewish teacher, prepares Jesus’ body for burial with a large quantity of fragrant spices. Such quantities were traditionally reserved for the bodies of kings. Why is it surprising that Nicodemus wants to give Jesus this kind of burial?
Question 11
What does this mean for us?
Tim Keller describes the crucifixion as utterly unique. Jesus took our place, the place of sinners. Though innocent, he received God’s judgement for our sins. This is how he is the Saviour of the world.
Tim Keller contrasts religious teachers who tell people how to reach God with Jesus, who comes to rescue people through his own actions. In Keller’s account, Christian salvation rests on Christ’s work rather than our achievements. (Paraphrase.)
What have you learned about yourself from Jesus’ death? Is Keller right? Is the cross how we are saved and where our sins are taken away?